Luciano Acosta scored on a penalty kick to tie the match in second-half stoppage time and then converted the first of FC Cincinnati's four straight successful penalty kicks in their Leagues Cup victory over visiting Sporting Kansas City on Monday night.
The teams were tied 3-3 at the end of the second half, forcing penalty kicks.
Brandon Vazquez also scored in regulation, assisted by Acosta, and duplicated the latter's success during PKs in the Leagues Cup Central 3 matchup.
Yuya Kubo and Matt Miazga added penalty-kick goals for FC Cincinnati, who were helped by an own goal from SKC goalkeeper John Pulskamp to cut into a 2-0 first-half deficit.
The scoring opened on an own goal by Cincinnati's Nick Hagglund in the ninth minute, and Dany Rosero made it 2-0 in the 12th on an assist from Gadi Kinda.
Erik Thommy and Khiry Shelton converted penalty kicks for SKC, but Remi Walter and Andreu Fontas failed on their attempts, giving FC Cincinnati the win.
Cincinnati dominated possession (58.1 per cent to 41.9 per cent), total shots (21-11) and shots on goal (8-4). Pulskamp made six saves, and Alec Kann made two at the other end.
Atlas 1, New York City FC 0
Aldo Rocha scored in the seventh minute and Atlas kept host New York off the board throughout to win the Leagues Cup East 3 match.
Luis Reyes set up the goal with a cross following a corner kick, and Rocha found the bottom right corner of the goal. Despite dominating possession (66.6 per cent to 33.4 per cent), NYCFC wasn't able to score.
Both teams finished with 10 shots, but while Atlas put five on goal, New York City only had two. Atlas' goalkeeper Camilo Vargas made one save, while NYCFC counterpart Luis Barraza made four.
Nashville SC 2, Rapids 1
MLS goals
Read on supersport.com