Due to the ongoing conflict with Hamas, Israel's tie was switched to Budapest and their hopes of making the finals of any major competition for the first time since the 1970 World Cup enjoyed a confident start. On the half-hour mark, Daniel Leo Gretarsson was punished for bringing down Eran Zahavi.
The veteran Israeli striker picked himself up to steer his penalty past Hakon Valdimarsson in the Iceland goal. The lead lasted less than 10 minutes, however, when Genoa's Albert Gudmundsson curled in a free-kick to equalise. Just three minutes before half-time Iceland, who made the quarter-finals at the 2016 Euros, were ahead.
Gudmundsson swept over a corner and midfielder Arnor Ingvi Traustason was on hand to lash the ball home off a deflection which wrong-footed Israel goalkeeper Omri Glazer. Israel's Roy Revivo was sent-off in the 73rd minute but his team were then handed a golden chance to equalise when Gudmundur Thorarinsson was penalised for handball.
However, this time Zahavi dragged his penalty wide and Iceland soon made him pay. In the 83rd minute Gudmundsson grabbed his second of the night after a surging run and then completed his hat-trick as the clock ran down.
"It's very disappointing. We were one goal ahead and then we conceded two easy goals before half-time," said Glazer. "It's never easy when it's 11 against 10, and sometimes you miss a penalty, it's part of football. Then we gambled more. We lost, and we need to look in the mirror at what we did well, and what not so well."
Iceland will now face Ukraine on Tuesday with the winner to claim a spot in this summer's finals in Germany. "We were lacking goals earlier in qualification last year, and now we have Albert Gudmundsson back, and he showed that he's a class
Read on besoccer.com