'What are they trying to hide?' - Andy Burnham questions Premier League over Everton evidence stance

Mayor of Greater Manchester Andy Burnham has questioned why the Premier League will not be publicly releasing evidence from Everton’s points-deduction appeal hearing.

The independent panel is due to share its verdict on November’s 10-point sanction this month with the process concluding a week ago. However, Premier League chief Richard Masters says key financial details about the case will not be disclosed. Appearing before the Government’s Department Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) committee in January, he was asked for minutes of the board meeting in which it was decided that the Toffees would be handed an unprecedented 10-point deduction.

Responding in a letter, Masters said: "As the committee will appreciate, being a private business, it is not our practice to provide or publish minutes of Premier League Board Meetings. Nor are we able to publish submissions the Premier League Board or executive make as part of confidential legal proceedings."

Everton points deduction fallout has left the Premier League devastated, reeling and embarrassed

Everton player ratings as Calvert-Lewin and five more good in Man City loss

Defending the Premier League’s heavy points sanction, Masters added: "At all times during this process, the Premier League has sought to treat the club fairly and with respect. Of course, as the competition organiser and administrator, it is also our role to ensure fairness for clubs that have adhered to the rules. That means enforcing our rulebook consistently and impartially."

Burnham, an Everton fan, says he is puzzled by the Premier League’s stance not to release evidence and says it only gives fuel to the idea that an independent regulator should be established. Taking to X (formerly Twitter), the